If You Liked the Movie “Fake”, Then There Is Another Movie You Should Definitely Watch.

Our relationships are the foundation of our lives: they shape our sense of security and our understanding of the world around us. When someone close to us suddenly and subtly changes, it can be unsettling, especially because it’s impossible to pinpoint exactly what has changed or why. These are the waters in which Hulu’s “Fake It,” a perfectly crafted tragicomedy about a teenager (Sam Nivola) who awakens from a brief coma convinced his mother (perfectly played by Connie Britton) has been replaced by a doppelganger, navigates. If you enjoyed the show (and similar shows ) and are looking for more intriguing stories about doppelgangers and impostors that resonate with you, you should definitely check out “Goodnight, Mom.”
Goodnight, Mommy (2015)
Goodnight Mommy is a psychological horror film , especially more so than Fake , and it explores the impostor mother theme much more strongly, but it only delves deeper into the darker aspects of the series (and be warned, this movie is very dark ).
A woman who identifies herself only as Mother returns from plastic surgery with her face completely covered in bandages. Her twin sons notice strange changes in her behavior that convince them she is not their real mother—she seems to completely ignore one of her sons and disciplines him much more severely than before. The boys also find evidence that reinforces their fears, including a photograph of their mother posing with a woman dressed exactly like her.
The boys’ attempts to get her to confess quickly spiral into madness, eventually leading to them tying her to the bed in an attempt to force her to admit she’s not their real mother. This all leads to a revelation as touching as the final explanation in “Faunia ” (though far darker and more brutal). The film is much more gritty than the series, but if you thoroughly enjoyed the premise, this is the more terrifying version you’ll want to watch. The original film is German; a remake starring Naomi Watts was released in 2022 , and while it’s quite good, the original is the right choice. Watch “Goodnight Mommy” on Kanopy or Plex , or rent it on Prime Video .
More movies like Fanatics
Looking for more impostor stories that explore the psychological and emotional consequences of suspecting someone’s identity has been replaced? Here are a few more films exploring this topic.
Hole in the Ground (2019)
The Hole in the Ground offers an inversion: a mother becomes convinced her son has been replaced by an impostor. While firmly rooted in the supernatural horror genre, the story continues to play the same game with the viewer: has Sarah (Shona Kerslake) gone mad, or has her son, Chris (James Quinn Markey), been replaced by a creature haunting the woods near their home? The film possesses the same unsettling energy, as Sarah tries to discern how much of her son’s altered behavior is a psychological projection of herself, and how much is clear evidence that he is no longer the same person—or perhaps even the same species. Watch The Hole in the Ground on HBO Max or rent it on Prime Video .
The Double (2014)
Based on the novella by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, The Double explores what happens when you’re replaced by a double. Simon (Jesse Eisenberg) is a loser: ignored at work, lonely, and silently pining for the girl Hannah (Mia Wasikowska) who lives across the street. One day, Simon gets a new coworker named James—and James looks exactly like Simon. But James is assertive, confident, and charming, which leaves Simon stunned. As the two versions of himself begin to vie for supremacy, Simon increasingly resorts to insane tricks to rid himself of the new, improved version of himself. If you enjoyed the psychological themes explored in The Fake , check out The Double. You can stream The Double on Kanopy , Hoopla , or Tubi , or rent it on Prime Video .
Enemy (2013)
On the one hand, Denis Villeneuve’s 2013 film follows a college professor named Adam (Jake Gyllenhaal) who discovers an actor named Anthony (also played by Gyllenhaal) who looks exactly like him. As he tracks down his doppelganger, their lives become intricately intertwined, culminating in tragedy and one of the most striking (and confusing) final shots in cinematic history. On the other, Enemy is a clever trick, exploring the human subconscious through dream logic and red herrings. If the best part of The Fake was the disorienting sense that the mystery lurking beneath the surface will explain everything, then Enemy is a perfect choice. Watch Enemy on HBO Max or rent it on Prime Video .
Possession (1981)
If you’re looking for a more profound, demented, and terrifying doppelganger story, Andrzej Zulawski’s 1981 film is a great choice. Partially inspired by his own experiences after a painful divorce, the story follows Mark (Sam Neill), a spy who returns to West Berlin during the height of the Cold War to discover that his wife, Anna (Isabelle Adjani), is cheating on him and wants a divorce. But Anna’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, and Mark meets their son’s teacher, Helene, who bears a striking resemblance to Anna. And that’s before Anna… well, sort of grows a replacement for Mark from a tentacle-like creature she keeps in her bathtub (and that’s just the beginning of how bizarre this film gets), resulting in two doppelgangers. Whether the film is literal or simply reflects the trauma of romantic betrayal and divorce is up to you, but Whiplash will definitely leave a mark. You can watch Whiplash online on Shudder , Kanopy , or Hoopla , or rent it on Prime Video .
Obsession (1976)
The film “Whiplash” explores the doppelganger effect from a different perspective. Cliff Robertson plays Michael Courtland, a wealthy businessman whose wife (Genevieve Bujold) and young daughter, Amy (Wanda Blackman), are kidnapped in 1959. When he follows police advice not to hand over the ransom money, both women appear to die in an explosion. Courtland spends the next 16 years hating himself until he meets a young woman, Sandra (also Bujold), who looks almost exactly like his late wife. He tries to make Sandra as much like his wife as possible and eventually proposes—but then Sandra is kidnapped in the same way his wife and daughter were 16 years earlier. This leads to a dizzying series of revelations and a surprising plot twist reminiscent of the Hitchcock classic “Vertigo.” Watch “Whiplash” on Prime Video .