Best Girl Scout Cookie Alternatives at the Grocery Store
Girl Scout cookies are not only delicious but also something of an American pastime. The problem, however, as we all know, is that they only appear once a year. If you don’t want to wait until early next year for a dose of Do-si-dos, a good alternative may already exist at your nearest grocery store. Several grocery store brands have attempted to make imitation Girl Scout cookies, and while they may not be the perfect replica of your favorite annual cookie, they quench the itch in the meantime.
Best Thin Mints Alternatives
Keebler Grasshoppers Cookies . Described on their website as “crispy mint cookies dipped in delicious fudge”, it’s not hard to see the parallels between the aforementioned cookie and Thin Mint. While they may not be the iconic Thin Mint, they are indeed a national brand that can be found in most grocery stores.
Back to Nature Fudge Mint Cookies. Back to Nature was founded in 1960 with a mission to offer delicious, plant-based snacks. Like traditional Thin Mint cookies, Back to Nature’s Fudge Mint cookies are also vegan. At the very least, it earned praise from Amazon user Marina E. Michaels , who says, “If you like thin mints, you’ll love these even more.”
Best Samoa Alternatives
Clover Valley Coconut Cookies and Fondant Cookies. Clover Valley Coconut and Fudge Cookies are Dollar General’s attempt to imitate Samoa. Have they been able to imitate? It’s up to you. What ‘s certain is that at $2, Clover Valley cookies are more wallet-friendly than their Girl Scout counterparts.
Benton’s Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies . One of the fastest growing grocery chains in the United States, so it’s important to know a few things before entering Aldi . One of them is their attempt at making Samoa – Benton’s Caramel Coconut Fudge cookies. Try it to see how it compares to the original; just don’t be surprised if they make you pack it yourself.
Best Lemon-Ups Alternatives
Pepperidge Farm Lemon Cookies . Committed to the cookie game, Pepperidge Farm is more than just the creators of Milanos. Their Lemon Cookie offering is an honest attempt at Girl Scout’s Lemon-Ups, which they did a great job of pairing its buttery flavor with a savory twist. Put a little frosting on that bad guy and now you’re really cooking on gas.
Shortbread Clover Valley with ice and lemon . Your eyes do not deceive you; this is the second appearance of the Clover Valley brand on this list. Dollar General was clearly trying to create something specific with their Clover Valley cookie brand, and I don’t blame them. Spoiler: you may well see this brand on this list again.
The best alternative to Toffee-tastics
Shortbread Trader Joe’s Coffee Toffee . Cookies are so difficult to replicate that I can sincerely recommend only one viable alternative. Trader Joe’s does a lot of things well , so it’s not hard to believe that their Girl Scout cookie imitation will be top notch.
Best Shamrock Alternatives
365 Butter shortbread cookies . Whole Foods 365 Butter Shortbread is the best imitation Girl Scout shamrock I’ve ever had. It is cheap? Rare products from Whole Foods. But is it available? Yes, and that’s more than you can say about Girl Scouts.
Dublin shortbread from Pepperidge Farm . A Pepperidge Farm classic, the Dublin Shortbread shortbread is a solid alternative for those looking to get rid of the shamrock itch. They are very similar in texture to the shamrock, which is a characteristic of good shortbread cookies.
The best alternative to Do-si-dos
Happy Belly cookies with peanut butter and cream. If entering the book, electronics, and clothing market wasn’t enough, Amazon has also entered the Girl Scout imitation cookie industry, and their Happy Belly Peanut Butter Crème cookies are a great option if you’re missing your usual routine. si-dos.
Best Tagalong Alternatives
Peanut Butter Filled Benton Cookies . Peanut butter and… chocolate?? This fairy tale is as old as the world. This is, once again, Aldi’s foray into the Girl Scout imitation cookie market. If you’re already picking up a box of their Samoan imitations, you can pick up these as well.
Clover Valley cookies filled with fudge-filled peanut butter . What did I tell you? You go to Dollar General, you can choose a Girl Scout imitation cookie. Pretty handy if you ask me; as long as you know which items to avoid in the dollar store.